Total Market Index

FundamentalETFs & Index Investing2 min read

Quick Definition

A broad market index that aims to represent the entire investable stock market of a country or region, including large, mid, small, and micro-cap stocks.

What Is Total Market Index?

A total market index tracks the performance of virtually all publicly traded stocks in a given market, providing the broadest possible diversification. Unlike the S&P 500 (which covers only 500 large-cap stocks), a total market index includes large, mid, small, and micro-cap companies.

Major Total Market Indexes:

IndexCoverageStocks
CRSP US Total Market IndexAll US stocks4,000+
Russell 30003,000 largest US stocks3,000
Wilshire 5000All US-listed stocks~3,500
FTSE Global All CapAll world stocks9,000+

Popular Total Market ETFs/Funds:

FundTracksExpense RatioHoldings
VTICRSP US Total Market0.03%4,000+
ITOTS&P Total Market0.03%3,700+
SWTSXSchwab Total Stock0.03%3,400+
FSKAXFidelity Total Market0.015%4,000+
VTFTSE Global All Cap0.07%9,800+

Total Market vs S&P 500:

FeatureTotal Market (VTI)S&P 500 (VOO)
Holdings4,000+500
Small-cap exposureYesNo
Mid-cap exposureYesLimited
Historical returnsVery similar (~0.1% difference annually)Very similar
DiversificationBroaderStill well-diversified

Why Choose Total Market:

  1. Maximum diversification — every investable US stock
  2. Small-cap premium — historically small-caps earn a slight premium
  3. No selection bias — no committee deciding which stocks to include
  4. Single-fund simplicity — one fund covers the entire market

Why It Matters: For most investors, a total market index fund (VTI or FSKAX) combined with an international fund (VXUS) and a bond fund (BND) creates a complete, low-cost portfolio — often called a "three-fund portfolio."

Total Market Index Example

  • 1VTI holds 4,000+ stocks including small companies like regional banks that the S&P 500 misses entirely
  • 2The three-fund portfolio (VTI + VXUS + BND) provides global diversification for under 0.05% average expense ratio