Commodity ETF

IntermediateETFs & Index Investing2 min read

Quick Definition

An ETF that provides exposure to physical commodities like gold, oil, or agricultural products, either through futures contracts, physical holdings, or commodity producer stocks.

What Is Commodity ETF?

A commodity ETF gives investors exposure to commodities — raw materials like gold, silver, oil, natural gas, and agricultural products — without having to directly buy and store physical goods or trade futures contracts.

Types of Commodity ETFs:

StructureExampleTracksConsideration
Physical-backedGLD, SLV, IAUActual gold/silver stored in vaultsClosest to spot price
Futures-basedUSO, UNGCommodity futures contractsSubject to contango/backwardation
Equity-basedXLE, GDXCommodity producer stocksCorrelated but not identical to commodity
Broad commodityDJP, GSGBasket of multiple commoditiesDiversified commodity exposure

Popular Commodity ETFs:

ETFCommodityExpense RatioStructure
GLDGold0.40%Physical
IAUGold0.25%Physical
SLVSilver0.50%Physical
USOCrude Oil0.60%Futures
DBAAgriculture0.85%Futures

The Contango Problem (Futures-Based ETFs): Futures-based commodity ETFs face "contango" — when future-month contracts cost more than near-month. Rolling from expiring to more expensive contracts creates a persistent drag on returns. This is why USO (oil ETF) can lose money even when oil prices are flat.

Why Invest in Commodities:

  1. Inflation hedge — commodities often rise with inflation
  2. Portfolio diversification — low correlation to stocks/bonds
  3. Geopolitical hedge — gold and oil respond to global events
  4. Real asset exposure — tangible assets vs. financial assets

Tax Considerations:

  • Physical commodity ETFs (GLD, SLV) are taxed as collectibles: 28% max capital gains rate
  • Futures-based ETFs get 60/40 tax treatment (60% long-term, 40% short-term)
  • Equity-based ETFs taxed like normal stock ETFs

Commodity ETF Example

  • 1GLD holds over 800 tons of physical gold in London vaults, making it one of the largest gold holders in the world
  • 2USO (oil ETF) lost 80%+ in early 2020 due to both oil price crash and severe contango in futures markets